Why do you think you stayed with me when I treated you so bad? Because you cared. That’s who you are. You care about Lucas because you know he loves you and you probably still care about me and Brooke because you know we love you too. Just face it, Peyton, you care.
1x01 The Places You Have Come To Fear The Most
Peyton: Dammit, Nathan! That CD was hard to find! It’s an import!
Peyton Sawyer Alphabet → Nathan
Peyton: All right, let me see that baby. Oh God.
Nathan: Not bad huh?
Peyton: Good work buddy.
Nathan: I made that.
Nathan: You were never happier.
Peyton: You were never hornier.